Add-On Review: Surgeon General

One of the tasks a healing lead is responsible for in most raiding groups is to assign healers to specific jobs within the raid. While this is common in 10-man raids, it is nearly universal in 25-man groups.1 Once I became the priest class lead, and later, guild officer and healing coordinator (being the add-on junkie I am), I began searching for a simple add-on I could use to make and announce healing assignments.

Surgeon General (SG) is what I settled on, after trying a couple others. Here is a shot of the configuration screen, courtesy of Curse.com (click to enlarge):

 

SurgeonGeneral Configuration Screen

 

SG is fully LibDataBroker-compliant, and supplies a little blue “SG” button that sits in my Fortress bar. Clicking that button opens the configuration screen. From there, I can select the Instance:

 

Instance Selection Box

 

and once I’ve done that, select the boss for whom I want to assign healers:

 

Boss Name Selection

 

If all your healers are within range, the Auto Fill button will plug them into the slots on the configuration screen. And while the capability isn’t there yet, the developer has told me he is working on incorporating communication between SG and CTRaid/oRA2 to auto-fill the tanks as well, which will make SG even simpler. (I think he’s been waiting for this review, which I told him last month I was planning.) ;)

Once these steps are done, it’s fairly simple to fill in the assignments. You can even do a whole wing of Naxx at a time, if you like.2 Click “Save” and the assignments, although not necessarily the people assigned, are saved. You can hit “Esc” to close the window, or click the Close button. Bringing the window up again with the “SG” button will restore everything you entered for this session (unless you reload your UI).

 

Assignments for Construct Wing

 

I should point out that if you correctly spell the healer’s name, his or her class symbol will appear to the left: You can see the Priest’s staff head next to my name in the screenshot. Then, should you need or want to reorder the list, simply drag the icon!3

As we move past Patchwerk and on to Grobbulus, I would erase the Patchwerk assignments, then click the “Enable” button for the Grobbulus column. Before each subsequent boss, uncheck the boss just downed, enable the next column, and so on. On a fight such as Malygos, you may in fact want to have different assignments for each phase (especially for Phase 3). SG easily supports such a configuration.

Note the “Report” checkboxes at the bottom center: Before you pull, it might be a good idea to let everyone (especially the healers!) know the assignments. When you click the Report button, you get something like this:

 

Report to Raid and Healers

 

The first four lines are to the raid; the last four are to the healer channel. Note the healer is listed first, then his or her assignment. Where multiple healers have the same assignment, all are listed together. So for this successful 25-man one-shot of Sartharion, three of us (Holy Priest, Shaman, Paladin, respectively) were assigned to raid heals; our Discipline Priest on the main tank, and another holy priest on the add tank.

In summary, Surgeon General is a compact, simple-to-use, highly effective tool for assigning raid healers. My guild has come to rely on it, and if I’m a little slow on getting out the word, even before we start buffing, I start getting queries in raid chat, healer chat, and whispers. (Tanks, it seems, don’t generally care who is healing them, as long as they know someone is.)

One final note: I alluded to having discussed SG with its developer, and I have. And in fact, Brimmstone has since become an active commenter here at the Aerie4. I’ve found him to be extremely approachable, and very eager to work with the healing community to improve SG. So thanks, Brimm, for a great tool, and I look forward to using SG for as long as you keep developing it!

  1. Note: I’ve never pugged a raid, so I’ve no idea if raiding assignments are made or just happen. I know if I ever DID pug a 25-man, I’d declare my intent to heal the MT, just so there would be no confusion about whether or not that was happening.
  2. Incidentally, the assignments shown in the screenshots, especially for Thaddius, aren’t necessarily actual healing assignments; they are for illustrative purposes only. /end disclaimer’
  3. I actually just found this out in another email from Brimm; I’m sure it’s in some documentation I never found. But now I know what to do when a healer drops out and a big blank space opens up in the middle of my list!
  4. I define “active commenter” as anyone with two or more comments in a 6-month period. ;)
 

QR CODE FOR THIS ARTICLE:

10 Responses to Add-On Review: Surgeon General
  1. Liore
    February 16, 2009 | 14:09

    Not to kind of sidestep the issue, but do you do healing assignments for most fights now? I used a mod like this one in the old 40-man days, and did more solid manual healing assignments in TBC, but I find thus far in WotLK healing assignments have gone the way of tank and CC assignments. (As in they don’t exist.)

    Now you have me wondering if I’m cheating my healing team out of a better sense of security or efficiency!

    Liore last blogged about Dear GC: Take my mana, please.

    • Kestrel
      February 16, 2009 | 18:35

      Yes, I do assign healing responsibilities for our 25-man raids. If nothing else, it gives me a better sense of security, knowing there won’t be an “OHhhh…I thought YOU were healing X…” moment.

      We also do tank assignments for a few fights; haven’t seen a CC requirement in ages though.

      For trash, the assignment is generally “Keep everyone alive.” But I find when I designate specific healers for our tanks, even for trash pulls, they tend to go more smoothly, since we don’t have 5 people trying to keep the MT up at the expense of other players.

      Once I convince everyone to run a LibHealComm 3.0 add-on, I expect the need for such specific assignments will go away as the healers understand better each other’s strengths.

  2. [...] has an Add-On Review: Surgeon General. This is an addon to simplify healer assignments in raids. Fortunately I don’t need to worry [...]

  3. Dark Spot in the Corner
    February 17, 2009 | 01:43

    Hi there!

    If you are still open to addon suggestions concerning healing assignements, I would recommend “Getting Things Healed”. It looks very promising and has a quick very smooth interface.

    URL: http://www.wowinterface.com/downloads/info10457-GettingThingsHealed.html
    :-)

  4. Xannder
    February 17, 2009 | 07:16

    I am the healing RL for Sol Invictus when our Healing CL isn’t on which due to RL has been quite often as of late. I use an addon called Getting Things Healed. I like the interface shown above for this addon but prefer the drag and drop nature of GTH.

    I just noticed that Dark Spot above me is suggesting the same thing. Stick with what your comfortable with but check that one out also, you may find you really like it!

    Thank god for addons, during BC we did everything through macros that spammed said channel, either of these addons make life much easier!

  5. Kestrel
    February 17, 2009 | 11:16

    As I mentioned in the article, I’d tried a few other options, including GTH. I just found SG to be simpler for me. GTH has the same limitation on scanning the raid as SG: Namely, anyone outside 30 yards or so won’t be scanned. By the time everyone is that close, we’re buffing and about 30 sec away from first pull, so that benefit isn’t so much. :)

    I should point out that with SG, you can drag healers around once you’ve added them, so if assignments change, it’s essentially drag and drop as well.

    Nothing against GTH; I just prefer the layout of SG. (Well, the fact that GTH won’t broadcast to my Healer channel is a drawback…it won’t broadcast to any channel below /5. Strange limitation, that!)

  6. Brimmstone
    February 17, 2009 | 14:08

    The issue with scanning the raid is a limitation of the Blizzard API. Talents are queried at the same time a unit is inspected and there is a distance limitation to how far away you can inspect somebody.

    I took a look as GTH and one thing I noticed in the documentation was the following: “The current set of assignments and phases saves when you close the window. So in the event of a crash, the set will be available when you reload the game.” This is, in fact, untrue as no addon is able to save data arbitrarily in the game; all data is saved on proper log-out. All addon saves use this “delayed-write” to prevent a user from writing an addon that would save in-game data to disk which could in turn be used for botting. This is why if your game crashes you lose data.

    One thing that I do like is the different icons for Disc vs Holy priests. It’s something I may have to add in the future.

    As far as people actually doing assignments these days, there are some fights where assignments are absolutely necessary. Having all your healers on one platform for Thaddius, or on the Live side for Gothik is a certain wipe. While it doesn’t take a long time to split your healers up for these fights, if you’re trying to move as quickly as possible it’s nice to be able to set these up ahead of time (like during loot) and just announce them when you get to these encounters.

  7. SuchANoob
    February 21, 2009 | 17:10

    I feel like an idiot but how do you open the addon?

    • Kestrel
      February 21, 2009 | 20:56

      If you’re using LibDataComm, you should have a blue “SG” icon available. Otherwise, simply type /sg.

  8. [...] Surgeon General- Kestrel over at Kestrel’s Aerie wrote a review of this one, check it out it is very helpful.  I’m currently using this one and [...]

Performance Optimization WordPress Plugins by W3 EDGE